The Pi Kappa Alpha (Pike) national organization says it will not permit a planned merger between the UChicago chapters of the Pike and Phi Delta Theta (Phi Delt) fraternities, upsetting an arrangement that would have allowed all members of Phi Delt to join Pike after the former disbands at the end of this academic year.
Subsequent conversations with the leadership of both fraternities revealed, however, some confusion between the two groups over what exactly the arrangement would entail.
In an email to the Maroon on November 6, Pike national organization Executive Vice President Justin Buck said that an article published by the Maroon discussing the merger was the “first notice” the national organization had of the proposal and that “mergers of this sort are prohibited by Pi Kappa Alpha, and all Fraternities, and will not be permitted.”
Arav Saksena, the former president of Phi Delt, originally described the planned merger in an interview with the Maroon last month. At the time, he did not distinguish between a full merger between the two chapters and offering currently uninitiated members the opportunity to instead pledge Pike.
Pike’s national rules only allow fully disaffiliated or uninitiated members of another fraternity to join theirs. The North American Interfraternity Conference’s (NIC) double-initiation rules also restrict initiated members of one fraternity from joining another until the member is confirmed as disaffiliated by their national fraternity. While Pike is in the NIC, Phi Delt is not.
But Henry Koepp, the external vice president of Pike at UChicago, said that any arrangement between the fraternities would only apply to previously uninitiated members. “We’re kind of bummed that it’s getting billed as a merger since it’s technically just us bidding a bunch of second-years, and a merger, as per our national organization’s rules, is not a thing that’s allowed,” Koepp said.
Uninitiated fraternity members, or “pledges,” are students who have begun a trial or orientation period required before fully joining a fraternity. Phi Delt pledges, as uninitiated members, have not officially become members of their fraternity, and their future membership in Pike would not be prohibited by the NIC bylaws.
Saksena told the Maroon last month that a representative from UChicago’s Pike chapter had contacted him and asked if he might “want to chat about a potential merger” after Phi Delt was suspended last spring. During initial discussions, Saksena said that after the merger was completed, members of Phi Delt would be invited to rush Pike in the upcoming year. Saksena did not differentiate between initiated and uninitiated students’ ability to rush.
“I don’t think that we were going to kick some people out… I wouldn’t have allowed that to happen. I’m not going to have half of our frat be allowed to join [and] the others not be allowed to join,” Saksena said this month when told about the ban on double-initiation.
UChicago’s Phi Delt chapter was suspended last spring for “repeated risk management violations” after it had been placed on probation for violating the fraternity’s alcohol-free housing policy. The chapter will remain inactive on campus through the end of the academic year, when it formally disbands, and vacated its house on University Avenue over the summer.
Saksena called concerns about calling the change a merger “a semantical concern” in his most recent interview.
“When we got shut down, obviously I went crazy and talked to a number of frats to try and have them sponsor us, and we quickly found out that there are policies where you can’t be a brother of a certain frat and join another one,” he said. “The way you get around that is [that] the old frat has to effectively renounce you and allow you to do that, and then you get a letter from them—which all the guys in Phi Delt have, because they shut us down.”
The proposed adoption of the uninitiated Phi Delt members into Pike, as Koepp described, does not clarify where current members of Phi Delt will go next year, when the academic year ends.
“We’d really like to clarify that we’re just taking the uninitiated guys who were formerly Phi Delt potential members but were never initiated,” Koepp said.
Editor’s note: Arav Saksena, the former president of Phi Delt, is the Maroon’s chief financial officer. He was not involved in the reporting or editing of this article.
