Evan Gershkovich, a reporter at the Wall Street Journal, discussed his imprisonment in Russia on fabricated espionage charges and the risks journalists working under authoritarian governments face during an October 21 event hosted at International House by UChicago’s Institute of Politics.
Gershkovich recounted the events leading up to his March 2023 arrest, his efforts to continue his reporting from a Russian prison, and the politics surrounding his release in a multinational prisoner exchange in August 2024—all subjects of his recent memoir, This Cursed Beautiful Land.
In conversation with Miriam Elder, CNN executive editor and former Moscow bureau chief for the Guardian, Gershkovich said Russia’s treatment of prisoners demonstrated how governments leverage political prisoners for international diplomacy.
“I was taken in a very specific way, held as a pristine package to be swapped for something in return. I was treated almost like a first-class citizen,” Gershkovich said, “It’s important to understand how calculating the Russian state can be in how it treats people. We aren’t all equal in that system.”
Gershkovich said conditions for foreign correspondents in Russia deteriorated significantly after the country’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. At the end of 2022, Russian President Vladimir Putin instructed the Federal Security Service (FSB), Russia’s domestic intelligence agency, to step up efforts to catch “traitors, spies and saboteurs.”
For Gershkovich, the most significant change was Russia’s change in surveillance methods—from Russian authorities openly following reporters to less detectable practices.
“It turns out the CIA has warned its station chiefs since the ’60s that when surveillance stops being visible, that’s the most dangerous time,” Gershkovich said, “In retrospect, I think they started making me feel comfortable once Putin gave the order.”
During his time in prison, Gershkovich continued to question why he had been targeted by the Russian government, as opposed to other journalists. Reflecting on why he might have been targeted, Gershkovich said Russia had previously sought to exchange American detainee Paul Whelan—a former Marine arrested on espionage charges in 2018 and released in 2024—for an FSB assassin, yet it hadn’t worked out.
“Putin wanted a spy, [the FSB] needed an American, and I was probably the easiest to set up,” Gershkovich said.
Gershkovich recounted how, in early 2023, he had been reporting on Russia’s shift toward a wartime economy, including its actions of raising military production and converting a car factory to weapons manufacturing. When Gershkovich met with a source who had information regarding Russia’s wartime production, six men in balaclavas entered the restaurant where they met and arrested him. In retrospect, Gershkovich concluded that the source must have either been an FSB agent for years or had been recruited by the bureau after the start of their relationship.
Gershkovich said that he only realized how the situation in Russia had changed when he was told that he was under arrest.
“Local police sometimes detain a foreign correspondent, maybe rough him up, call Moscow, and are told to let him go,” Gershkovich said, “But the FSB is the Praetorian Guard; it answers directly to Putin. This was a plan from on high. That was pure fear.”
Gershkovich said that during his sixth day in Lefortovo, Moscow’s historic FSB prison, he began thinking of himself as a reporter again.
“I can’t change the fact that I’m here, and this is pretty interesting, so I might as well report on it,” Gershkovich said, “It gave me a sense of purpose. Which other reporter gets to talk to FSB officials, have these kinds of cellmates, or learn how the prison system works from the inside?”
Gershkovich also recalled how his lawyers helped him find meaning in a legal system where the outcome of his trial seemed predetermined.
“[My lawyer] wanted me to read out in court Article 48 of the Russian Constitution, the right to choose your legal counsel, which by then had been so trampled it barely existed,” Gershkovich said, “I said, ‘With all due respect, what’s the point?’ He got mad and said, ‘One day this system will come crumbling down, and we’re trying to preserve in the record some semblance of legal norms to rebuild from.’ I think that’s the most moved I’ve been in my life.”
Gershkovich acknowledged that releasing convicted assassins in return for wrongfully detained prisoners could encourage governments to take more political hostages. However, he also argued that refusing to negotiate carried a moral cost.
“At the end of the day, it’s a values question,” Gershkovich said. He acknowledged that releasing a state assassin means justice isn’t carried out but noted that political hostages are still human lives that should be helped. He also noted that it is important to free wrongfully detained people, even if it risks encouraging future detentions.
When asked about how his experience changed what he believes a journalist’s role is in authoritarian states or conflicts, Gershkovich mentioned colleagues killed while reporting on the war in Ukraine.
“We talk about journalists’ bravery, and it is brave,” Gershkovich said, “But as a former colleague at the New York Times once told me, ‘You can’t tell the story if you’re dead.’”
Gershkovich also argued that reporting from authoritarian states becomes more difficult when governments are willing to arrest correspondents as political pawns, noting that a Japanese journalist was taken hostage in Russia on fabricated espionage charges as recently as October 14. Gershkovich also pointed out that newsrooms in Russia have largely prohibited reporting on sensitive topics.
Gershkovich concluded that in today’s political environment, laws are applied arbitrarily, making it necessary for newsrooms to recognize that almost anything reporters do can be interpreted as a crime.
“I don’t think the journalist’s role has changed at all; the work is vitally important,” Gershkovich said. “But understanding where the lines are is really important.”
