This article includes references to sexual assault.
A woman filed a lawsuit against UChicago’s chapter of Alpha Delta Phi and its national organization Monday claiming that a fraternity member sexually assaulted her at a party on February 7 and alleging both organizations failed to take precautions despite multiple reported sexual assaults by members at the house.
The 19-year-old plaintiff—identified only as “Jane Doe”—was not a University of Chicago student, one of her lawyers, Georgia Booth, told the Maroon in an interview.
The University of Chicago was also named in the lawsuit as a respondent in discovery, which means that it will be asked to provide information during the case’s fact-finding process. It may be added as a full defendant in the future if evidence obtained during the discovery process warrants it, Booth said.
According to the complaint, Doe was greeted upon her arrival at the frat party by the alleged perpetrator of the assault, a member of Alpha Delta Phi’s UChicago chapter, who gave Doe a shot of alcohol and encouraged her to drink it. “Almost immediately” after drinking, the lawsuit says, Doe began to feel “unsteady and lightheaded.”
Doe alleges that at that point, the fraternity member led her upstairs—an area closed to non-members—to a bedroom and sexually assaulted her. The complaint states that Doe told him multiple times that she felt “unsteady and lightheaded,” but he ignored her. The complaint also says that, while in the bedroom, Doe “lost all physical and verbal ability to refuse” him and that he continued to make sexual advances despite her inability to consent. Although she “plead[ed]” with the frat member to wear a condom, he refused.
After the alleged assault, Doe says that she was left alone and unconscious in the bedroom, and that her friend was prevented by other members of the fraternity from going upstairs to locate her. Only after another member of Alpha Delta Phi saw Doe unconscious was her friend allowed to go upstairs, where she found Doe unresponsive in the bedroom.
According to the complaint, Doe struggled to speak when leaving the bedroom and required assistance to walk and exit the fraternity house. She found bloodstains in her underwear and reported the assault to the Chicago Police Department (CPD) the morning after.
A CPD spokesperson confirmed to the Maroon on Tuesday that an investigation into the alleged assault is ongoing.
In a statement to the Maroon, Alpha Delta Phi’s national organization said that it had suspended the fraternity member in question after being made aware of the allegations. The national organization did not specify how soon after the incident that was.
In the days following the reported assault, the University of Chicago Police Department (UCPD) reached out to Doe and created an incident report in response, according to the complaint, but declined to provide Doe with any case records without a subpoena.
A University spokesperson told the Maroon in a statement that the allegations were “very disturbing” and that the University remains “committed to addressing and preventing incidents of sexual assault.” The spokesperson also reiterated that the University is not a defendant in the lawsuit but said the University will cooperate by providing information, is “prepared to help the Chicago Police Department in its investigation,” and “will take appropriate further steps as new information emerges.”
Fraternities are not formally recognized by UChicago, but the University has previously said that “all University students are subject to University policies and disciplinary procedures.” Disciplinary records for academic year 2025–26 have not yet been published.
Booth contended, however, that “the phrasing ‘not recognized by the University’ is something that institutions like UChicago use to protect themselves, when I think it’s clear that the opposite is true. These fraternities would not exist without the University of Chicago being there.”
“From our perspective and from our initial investigation, this is not just an isolated issue. This is something that is systemic and has been present on University of Chicago’s campus for a long time, and… there has been no effort to remediate or change the culture,” Booth said.
UChicago’s chapter of Alpha Delta Phi has been investigated by police multiple times since 2009 for reports of sexual assault at its fraternity house. The complaint alleges that the University, as well as both Alpha Delta Phi’s UChicago chapter and national organization, were “aware of the danger of sexual assault by fraternity members” at the frat house.
In January 2009, the suit alleges, two different sexual assaults were reported within five days of each other at the Alpha Delta Phi house. In the second incident, which occurred on January 15, the victim had to be transported to the emergency room via ambulance.
Both assaults, the suit claims, were investigated by CPD and UCPD; CPD’s incident reporter only lists the first—which took place on January 10, 2009—and UCPD’s online repository does not include incidents from before the beginning of the 2010 fiscal year.
In September 2022, an anonymous post on the Instagram account @shareyourstoryuchicago described another assault by a member that occurred after a party at the Alpha Delta Phi house.
According to the lawsuit, Alpha Delta Phi’s national organization was made aware of all three reported incidents but did not impose any kind of suspension or sanctions on its UChicago chapter, and never enforced requirements that residential floors of the house be secured during fraternity parties. The complaint also alleges that between 2009 and 2026, the fraternity received more reports of sexual misconduct involving their members and social events, including through its own internal reporting processes.
The complaint alleges that, on the night of Doe’s reported assault, UChicago’s Alpha Delta Phi chapter failed to enforce the national organization’s health and safety procedures, and although there were fraternity members restricting access to upper floors, no sober monitors were present to intervene when the two went upstairs.
The suit also claims that the party did not have a guest list and that Doe was not asked for identification when she arrived at the party, in violation of the Alpha Delta Phi national organization’s alcohol policy.
At the time of publication, Alpha Delta Phi’s UChicago chapter had not responded to a request for comment.
The suit comes a week after another reported sexual assault of a non-student on campus, at the Alpha Epsilon Pi fraternity house a block north of Alpha Delta Phi on University Avenue, for which the investigation is ongoing.
Nathaniel Rodwell-Simon contributed reporting.
