The fall term has started at the University of Chicago. Fifty-eight percent of the second-year class is male, as was slightly more than 56 percent of the College last spring. This stands in stark contrast not only to national statistics—in fall 2023, 42 percent of undergraduates in the United States were male—but also to UChicago’s peers: Harvard’s incoming class in 2025 was 48 percent male, while at both Yale and Princeton, men were 49 percent of the incoming class.
How in the world could UChicago get this stunning ratio, and what does it mean?
These numbers derive from the Common Data Set (CDS), a voluntary initiative in which institutions of higher education report information according to a shared set of metrics and definitions. In lay terms, you might say these are the numbers that universities themselves compile and give to U.S. News & World Report for their annual rankings.
The University of Chicago did not end up with an overwhelmingly male class by virtue of its applicant pool. As splendid reporting by the Maroon has already discussed, women applicants outnumbered men, 24,578 to 19,929. UChicago simply elected to admit 5.9 percent of men but only 3.5 percent of women. (It admitted none of the 1,026 applicants of “unknown” sex.)
Nor is this a one-year aberration or a mistake. In academic year 2021–22, UChicago admitted 5.9 percent of women but 7.2 percent of men. In 2022–23, it admitted 4.7 percent of women but 6.3 percent of men. In 2023–24, it admitted 4 percent of women but 5.7 percent of men. And in 2024–25, it admitted 3.7 percent of women but 5.6 percent of men. In other words, in 2021 men were only 22 percent more likely to be admitted than women, but that advantage has grown every year, from 22 percent to 34 percent, to 43 percent, to 52 percent, to an astonishing 66 percent.
The gap between the rates of admissions is widening every single year: It is becoming easier and easier to be admitted to UChicago if you are male rather than female.
The most recent year’s numbers therefore represent simply an intensification of a long-term trend. Among many results, as already stated, one of significance is that 56.4 percent of Chicago’s degree-seeking undergraduates as of last spring were male. Another is that UChicago’s national ranking for selectivity, currently No. 4, depends crucially on its rejecting so many women. Its selectivity of men alone would drop it out of the top 10. By contrast, Chicago’s selectivity for women alone would place it in the first position in the country.
In short, the degrees of male students are enhanced by the luster of a selective process to which they were not equally exposed.
How do you run a fair and rational admissions process and yet make women work so much harder than men to get the same result? Of course, it’s not easy to do college admissions nowadays; among matriculating students who reported their high school GPA, the average score was 4.54! Selecting from within such a pool must be hard.
The CDS asks universities to rank the relative importance of certain academic and nonacademic criteria in their admissions process from “very important” to “not considered.” Among academic criteria, the University of Chicago treats as “very important”: rigor of secondary school record, application essay, and recommendations. In third position, one above “not considered” at all, it names class rank, academic GPA, and standardized test scores.
In essence, any metric of student achievement that could be compared without interpretive mumbo jumbo is discounted in favor of modes of analysis that leave judgment—and success—in the hands of persons who are unaccountable and processes that are deliberately obscure. Whatever women talk about in their essays, and whatever is written about them in recommendations, apparently doesn’t cut it. Perhaps their recommendations are written by women?
Among nonacademic criteria, UChicago ranks in first position—as very important—the following: extracurricular activities, “talent/ability,” and “character/personal qualities.” It is not possible from the outside to know how the admissions office at the University of Chicago assesses “talent” or “character,” but apparently men have those qualities in abundance. Women? Not so much.
(The University previously declined to answer specific questions about the gender composition of the College or its admissions practices related to gender. In its nondiscrimination statement, the University says that it accepts applicants “on the basis of individual merit” and prohibits sex discrimination in its academic programs.)
Deliberately tilting the sex ratio of the undergraduate population has important consequences for academic life on several levels. Nationally, STEM fields skew heavily male, while humanistic and interpretive social science disciplines skew female. Distorting the sex ratio to a point of substantial imbalance has the intellectual effect of creating a gendered and epistemic monoculture—precisely the opposite of what a university should want and, indeed, what the University of Chicago claims to want.
What is more, since tuition revenue is allocated within the University according to enrollment, going out of one’s way to reject women contributes to the delivery of resources to particular (favored) departments while depriving other (disfavored) departments of revenue that a gender-neutral admissions policy would surely have yielded.
There are other, non-academic factors that correlate with gender that deserve investigation, some of which may have played a role in UChicago’s decision to admit men less selectively than women. Historically, it is almost certainly the case that men were responsible for the majority of gifts to the University. Perhaps it is hoped that a predominantly male body of alumni will give at a higher rate than would a gender-balanced one? But there are also correlations that should impel serious scrutiny of practices that are already, on the face of them, unfair. For example, a complex body of literature suggests that imbalanced sex ratios in a population correlate with heightened rates of sexual violence.
We do not know why UChicago acts as it does. The CDS initiative does not ask universities to explain themselves. Mostly, that is a virtue; the project aims to provide information, gathered according to standard definitions and presented in the same format, that can be compared across institutions. The object is transparency and intelligibility. This, it turns out, is not how universities analyze applications. One might have thought the long history of bias in university admissions would have taught all institutions of higher education not to rely on magical categories like “character” to distort their numbers. At the very least, it appears that the University of Chicago has not learned this lesson.
The Maroon independently verified all claims for which evidence was not publicly available.
Clifford Ando is the Robert O. Anderson Distinguished Service Professor in the Departments of Classics and History at UChicago.

Callum Ross / Oct 7, 2026 at 2:08 pm
It is interesting that the percentage of applicants with “unknown” sex (2.3%) is 100 times larger than the percentage in the population (0.02%). It would be interesting, and potentially important, to disambiguate sex and gender in these discussions.
Stan Horowitz / Oct 7, 2026 at 10:52 am
Have you considered that men might be more likely to apply early decision? Given UChicago’s ED-oriented approach to admissions, that could drive the results. Will the admissions office tell you? Great reporting!