Skip to Main Content
The University of Chicago’s Independent Student Newspaper since 1892

Chicago Maroon

The University of Chicago’s Independent Student Newspaper since 1892

Chicago Maroon

The University of Chicago’s Independent Student Newspaper since 1892

Chicago Maroon

Stories and content by Manasi Vydyanath

Brendel, Takács, and the concept of narratives

By Manasi Vydyanath / February 28, 2006
“Forcing a comparison” is usually the phrase that comes to mind when a reviewer attempts to critique two concerts in one article. However, occasions exist when distinct performances work together to illustrate a critical point so perfectly that one is inclined to agree with Shakespeare: Chance fashions events much better than one could lay down...

Orchestra excels with modern MacMillan, but can’t save Schumann’s excesses

By Manasi Vydyanath / January 31, 2006
The highlight of the St. Paul Chamber Orchestra’s January 22 performance was undoubtedly Veni, Veni Emmanuel, a concerto for percussion and orchestra by James MacMillan. It’s one of those rare modern compositions that appears and deserves to evade Slonimsky’s law of recognition, having received over 400 performances since its premiere at the BBC proms in...

Lyric Opera’s La Cenerentola makes a fun but flawed Cinderella story

By Manasi Vydyanath / November 8, 2005
The curtains went down this Friday upon the Lyric Opera’s last performance of Rossini’s La Cenerentola this season, to an enthusiastic but slightly uncertain audience. Their hesitancy was well occasioned, for while certain aspects of the production were absolutely brilliant, the crucial character of the eponymous protagonist left much to be desired. Vesselina Kasarova played...

Chicago debut of masterful duo evokes nymphs and nightmares

By Manasi Vydyanath / November 4, 2005
It was a concert of brilliant combinations and one uncalled-for interjection—a subtle oration with a hastily added anecdote. The pre-announced, original program was refreshing in its consistency; it made no attempt at combining modernity with antiquity for the sake of comforting temporal symmetry. However, the actual program notes of the evening contained two selections from...

Current CSO offering pales in comparison to summer series

By Manasi Vydyanath / September 30, 2005
After the incandescent series of concerts this summer at Ravinia, the Chicago Symphony Orchestra seemed a pale specter of itself last Friday. The cohesion, energy, and technical flair that characterized almost every performance at the festival seemed to have evaporated, leaving behind an apathy reminiscent of the draughtsman going back to work after three months...

Classical music from 1904 Vienna to today’s Chicago

By Manasi Vydyanath / May 19, 2005
The Chicago Symphony Orchestra played Alban Berg’s brilliant Chamber Concerto under the equally brilliant Pierre Boulez this Monday. I was to review that event, but due to Chicago traffic, I got to Symphony Hall sometime around intermission. Of course, I was much too late to write a decent concert review, and therefore, feeling vaguely irresponsible,...

The aesthetic brilliance of Toscanini and Furtwangler

By Manasi Vydyanath / May 17, 2005
Interpretation is an art that revolves around the definition of perspectives—in the crucible of analysis, most of the differences in performance come down to whether the artist creates the work from outside, looking in, or from the inside, looking out. Last Friday, the Akademie für Alte Musik presented a beautiful exploration into both possibilities; they...

Queen of Romanticism Michelle DeYoung needs to expand her empire

By Manasi Vydyanath / April 25, 2005
The concert was a portrait of the exquisite importance and the excruciating fragility of specialization—Michelle DeYoung, the quintessential Wagnerian mezzo-soprano—sang Haydn, Debussy, Strauss, Mahler, and Weill in a chamber recital at Mandel Hall last Friday. The entirety of the evening can be encapsulated in the preceding sentence, for all its implications materialized unerringly. She was...

Chicago Symphony Orchestra defies convention with contemporary works

By Manasi Vydyanath / February 25, 2005
It was an exquisite piece of aesthetic bookkeeping. The Chicago Symphony Orchestra (CSO) presented four works by contemporary composers, two of them world premieres, in a program that seemed more keenly aware of the beauty of classification than combination. The pieces were brilliant, eloquently symbolizing the postmodern emphasis on the unconventional opinion. If last Wednesday’s...

Haydn, Boulez, and Bartók: Perspective is everything

By Manasi Vydyanath / February 18, 2005
Every story has several interpretations. One could choose to look at the story of the ant and the grasshopper from the perspective of Aesop or Somerset Maugham. The Aesopian perspective on the Chicago Symphony Orchestra concert last Friday would assert that the Haydn symphony (which opened the evening) was poorly rendered and artistically unnecessary. In...

Netherlands Wind Ensemble plays Mozart better than that guy in the wig

By Manasi Vydyanath / February 18, 2005
The concert was a Haydnesque variation upon Mozart, an invention based around fragmentation and bifurcation. The renowned Netherlands Wind Ensemble presented one of Mozart’s most piquant and perhaps most elusive pieces: the Gran Partita in B flat, scored for 12 winds and a double bass. The piece is structured in seven movements, and its performance...

O’Riley and the Miró Quartet: “We Agree!”

By Manasi Vydyanath / January 28, 2005
The concert last Friday at Mandel Hall was an eloquent portrayal of the sheer importance of artistic dissent. Christopher O’Riley and three members of the Miró quartet (violinist Sandy Yamamoto was unable to perform, due to illness) began the evening in such consumate technical and aesthetic concurrence that they transformed expressive accord into interpretive homogeneity....

Peering into Shakespeare’s mirror: Is art useless?

By Manasi Vydyanath / January 21, 2005
The separation of art from the exigency of usefulness is one of the more spectacular bifurcations in the history of aesthetics. It is a brilliant example of setting up a dichotomy where none exists—and of the far-reaching consequences of a “mere” philosophical schism. The modern variant of the argument against art as a commodity runs...

Of variations, innovations, bestsellers, and vampires

By Manasi Vydyanath / January 7, 2005
The death of classical music is a topic whose timelessness is only matched by its ability to precipitate a lively conversation. In the modern critical context, the Malthusian eye appears to have shifted from generalized demise to ossification; the question is no longer whether classical music will die, but whether it will cease to be...

Le Concert Spirituel: lively listening, inspired critique

By Manasi Vydyanath / November 12, 2004
Ernest: “You are incorrigible. But, seriously speaking, who needs art criticism? If [an artist’s] work is easy to understand, no explanation is necessary…” Gilbert: “And if his work is incomprehensible, an explanation is wicked.” —Oscar Wilde, Critic as Artist Le Concert Spirituel’s performance last Friday seemed exquisite enough to provoke such a statement, and complete...

Pianist riffs on Radiohead; eighth blackbird fly high

By Manasi Vydyanath / November 2, 2004
A brilliant, thought-provoking concert that left very little to chance, Contempo’s performance last Tuesday was as meticulously structured as a Bach fugue. The evening was a double bill: the first half featuring classical music, and the second a jazz-inspired piano recital by the mesmerizing Brad Mehldau. The classical repertoire was something of a reprise—all the...

Two ensembles present compelling collaboration

By Manasi Vydyanath / October 28, 2004
In many ways, the Contempo embody the quintessence of classical music-making in our times —as well as provide a tantalizing glimpse of what they might become. Founded by Ralph Shapey at the University of Chicago in the fall of 1964, the Contemporary Chamber Players were envisaged as a forum for the performance of modern classical...

Chicago venues showcase classical music talent

By Manasi Vydyanath / October 27, 2004
These are scintillating times: classical music is in a state of unprecedented and unparalleled metamorphosis. Some claim that it will not outlast the next decade. Others maintain that we are in the midst of a renaissance. Even as you read these words, styles are being created, idioms explored, concepts forged, and music is being written...

Romanticism’s finest dazzles at Symphony Hall

By Manasi Vydyanath / October 6, 2004
The evening opened with Maurice Ravel’s Piano Concerto for left hand in D, one of his most turbulent pieces. Composed in 1931, it is more of an extended cadenza than a concerto; the orchestra exists merely to highlight the piano, which gives vent to tormented, virtuoso passages and desperate lyrical flights that almost threaten to...

World premieres and the importance of listening

By Manasi Vydyanath / September 18, 2004
Every premiere could potentially be the concert, unveiling a work that precipitates the present into the past, and forges infinitely many futures in its own image. A concert that presents a groundbreaking advancement not only of expression, but the very nature of expression. Reviewing new music is consequently one of the most important and exciting...

Glen Flora Ensemble parodies Haydn

By Manasi Vydyanath / June 8, 2004
It was an intriguing concert—executed with a superb sense of programmatic counterpoint. The Glen Flora Ensemble commenced with Haydn’s charming trio in D-major. At the heart of the work lies a captivating ingenuity, something that pianist Elizabeth Buccheri seemed curiously unwilling to portray. She chose to give a reading that focussed on elements of Sturm...

Kremerata Baltica Quintet taste perfection with rendition of Shostakovich

By Manasi Vydyanath / May 24, 2004
The concert opened with a shadowy 12-tone row that shimmered forth from the viola, whispering of possibilities made poignant because they could not exist. The ghostly fragments drifted into the upper strings, transforming themselves into a yearning contemplation in minor seconds and major ninths. The outlines dissolved, and in the spectral silence that followed, a...

Kent Nagano raises interpretation issues with Chicago Symphony Orchestra

By Manasi Vydyanath / April 27, 2004
The most intriguing part of the Chicago Symphony Orchestra’s concert—conducted by the superlatively elegant and Beecham-esque Kent Nagano—was Ichiro Nodaïra’s orchestration of the first fugue, the canon at the octave, and the canon at the tenth from Bach’s legendary Kunst der Fuge. The first piece was orchestrated relatively traditionally, true to the fugue’s austere, ascetic...

Berstein piece enlivens Gilbert’s turn at “superstar” conducting

By Manasi Vydyanath / April 9, 2004
This concert—conducted by the accomplished Alan Gilbert—opened with Sibelius’ symphonic poem Night Ride and Sunrise and closed with Nielsen’s sinfonia espansiva. These were nice, predictable works, impeccably executed but quite uninteresting. The former seems to deserve its relative obscurity—its few resurrections, in the name of artistic curiosity, serve to convince us that its rarity is...

Romanticism tempers Brahms and Beethoven for remarkable concert

By Manasi Vydyanath / April 2, 2004
It was easily one of the most remarkable concerts of the season, superbly programmed and brilliantly performed—the kind of event that leaves a critic with very little to say but much to discuss. Maxim Vengerov and Fazil Say interpreted the repertoire with a rare synthesis of drama and power—integrating their overarching, stereoscopic vision with an...

Chicago Symphony Orchestra: Two out of three ain’t bad

By Manasi Vydyanath / March 12, 2004
The Chicago Symphony Orchestra, with Charles Dutoit conducting, presented a curiously polarized concert last Saturday, with brusque oppositions of extreme ennui and superb expressiveness. The program commenced with Fauré’s Pelléas et Mélisande suite Op.80 and ended with excerpts from Prokofiev’s Romeo and Juliet, both variations upon one of the most popular themes in the history...

St. Lawrence Quartet gives clarinestist Todd Palmer the strings to fly

By Manasi Vydyanath / March 2, 2004
Intriguing, refreshing, piquant, powerful…these were some of my impressions of the performance last Friday by the St. Lawrence String quartet (with Geoff Nuttall and Barry Shiffman on violin, Lesley Robertson on viola, and Chris Costanza on cello.) They began with Joseph Haydn’s Op. 64, no. 2 in B minor, followed by Maurice Ravel’s ravishing quartet...

Barenboim and Serkin collaborate on classics with mixed results

By Manasi Vydyanath / February 24, 2004
The concert by the Chicago Symphony Orchestra—Daniel Barenboim conducting, Peter Serkin as piano soloist—on the February 17 included Bach’s Concerto for Two Harpsichords, BWV 1061; Schoenberg’s Piano Concerto Op. 42; and Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony. Structurally and aesthetically, the Bach concerto seemed discongruous. One could perceive that it had been placed there to illustrate a historical...

Arias endear audience to century-old opera

By Manasi Vydyanath / January 27, 2004
In a concert review, it’s risky business to pronounce something good. If you don’t disparage at least two out of three performances you review, your criticism loses credibility. You gain the reputation of being naïve and too easy to please, and everyone ignores you. The surest way to acquire fame is to brilliantly demolish something...
Donate to Chicago Maroon
$4,110
$5,000
Contributed
Our Goal