For most UChicago undergraduate students, summer break consists of internships, family time, summer classes, or traveling. For second-year Nikolas Polsinelli, however, this past summer was spent preparing for Jeopardy!.
Polsinelli, a member of UChicago’s Quiz Bowl team, is a longtime Jeopardy! fan. The iconic quiz television show was a permanent fixture in his household, where he grew up watching it with his parents. Polsinelli was not the first member of his family to audition, either: his mother auditioned herself a few years ago. “That was a process that I watched her go through, and so I thought that I could perhaps get on [the show] as well,” Polsinelli recalled.
The first step toward appearing on Jeopardy! is taking the online Anytime Test, a test that becomes available to anyone in the United States or Canada once they are 18. This test screens applicants who are able to meet the quiz-knowledge criteria for the show. So, for Florida native Polsinelli, taking the test was a matter of when, not if. “I just sat down and did [the test] pretty much as soon as I was eligible. Then, if you do well enough on that, you are moved on to the next round,” Polsinelli said.
As Polsinelli proceeded through the rounds, taking more tests and meeting with producers, the possibility of competing on Jeopardy! started to look less like a dream and more like a tangible reality. Finally, in October 2025, the Jeopardy! team reached out to Polsinelli about appearing on the show. In the midst of his first-year midterms, however, Polsinelli had some reservations. “Since that was my first quarter, I was apprehensive. It probably could have worked out, but to have to fly out to LA and record everything [in] midterm season would not have been ideal,” he explained.
The scheduling struggles continued after October. Although Polsinelli intended to appear on the show this past spring, that did not pan out either. However, Polsinelli was determined to work things out with the the Jeopardy! production team, and Polsinelli finally secured a time at the end of August.
Having finally booked his spot on Jeopardy!, Polsinelli would encounter one last difficult obstacle ahead of the episode’s airing: keeping the taping a secret over the summer. “It was definitely hard not to share with people where I was,” Polsinelli recalled. “Some people had asked me, because they have my location, ‘Hey, what are you doing in California?’ and I just responded, ‘Oh, nothing in particular, just in LA.’”
Ready to show off his quiz bowl skills, Polsinelli was flown out to Los Angeles to tape his episodes. Since it was the first time he had been to the city, Polsinelli spent his first day there acting like a tourist with his family. When he returned to his hotel around 10 p.m. that night, he wanted to prepare his outfit for the next day. To his horror, though, Polsinelli realized he didn’t have any of his dress shirts. “That was probably the most nervous I’ve been in my life,” Polsinelli admitted.
While intensely nerve-racking, the clothing emergency didn’t faze Polsinelli during actual taping. “Pretty much as soon as the episode started, I was sort of just in a groove and I felt fine,” Polsinelli said. Polsinelli’s background in quiz bowl, both in high school and college, aided him during each round. While one may think that an appearance on national television would be nerve-inducing, Polsinelli stressed that he had “been more nervous.. Some competitions I was at in high school, like national finals for History Bowl [in] 12th grade, were pretty nerve-racking.”
Luckily for Polsinelli, he was also not the first UChicago-affiliated person to appear on Jeopardy!, meaning he had someone to give their advice from their time on the show. Most notably, recent UChicago graduate Liam Starnes (A.B. ’25) had his own impressive run on the show. Leading up to Polsinelli’s appearance on the show, Starnes was someone that Polsinelli was able to speak with and get advice from. “There have been a lot of people who are affiliated with the University of Chicago in some way [who have] also been affiliated with Jeopardy! in some way. I don’t think that’s an accident. I do think that part of it is selection. Some of the people that might select the University of Chicago as the place they attend college are also the sorts of people that might be into Jeopardy!,” Polsinelli explained.
Polsinelli even leaned on his first year of college education to answer a few of the questions, explaining, “There were definitely a few clues that I think I specifically learned during my hum Core last year, for example, and I was like, ‘Wait a minute, I was taught that at some point this last year.’” Polsinelli continued, “I think that in a broad sense, the UChicago experience has helped me, and probably several others, but also there are some specific instances where it is a specific fact that I learned at the University of Chicago as well.”
Perhaps most importantly, Polsinelli’s experience and calmness on taping day led to a fierce show of Jeopardy! wits. In his first appearance on the show, Polsinelli cleaned out the World Geography category and was the only contestant to correctly answer the final question. His dominance would not stop there, continuing into the following night, when he finished with a sizable lead over his competitors. However, all reigns must come to an end, and for Polsinelli, it was an absolute nail-biter: a singular dollar decided the difference between first and second place. All in all, Polsinelli ended his win streak with over $40,000 in winnings.
Polsinelli offered advice to Jeopardy! hopefuls that, “There is no need to be apprehensive about anything related to the process. If you have any interest in applying, you absolutely should. As for preparation, more is better, but don’t drive yourself into the ground worrying about it. At some point, you’ll get up there and it’ll be a category you know absolutely nothing about and there’s nothing you can do about it. And if you can piece something together, that’s great. And if not, it happens.”
Nikolas Polsinelli was not the first UChicago student to appear on Jeopardy! and he hopefully won’t be the last.
