The University of Chicago’s Independent Student Newspaper since 1892

Chicago Maroon

The University of Chicago’s Independent Student Newspaper since 1892

Chicago Maroon

The University of Chicago’s Independent Student Newspaper since 1892

Chicago Maroon

Holy rigamarole

The Philosophy Club, Secular Student Alliance, and InterVarsity Christian Fellowship debated God’s role in morality at Stuart Monday.

[img id=”78556″ align=”alignleft”]

You can’t spell “g-o-o-d” without “g-o-d,” but can you be good without God?

The Philosophy Club, Secular Student Alliance, and InterVarsity Christian Fellowship all thought they had the answer, at a debate called “Do you need God to be good?”

The debate, which took place in Stuart on Monday night, was moderated by Philosophy professor Michael Kremer, and co-sponsored by the three associations. The 60-person-capacity room was at overflow; people sat in the aisles, on the floors, and would-be attendees were turned away.

“We are doing this to give people a chance to think and explore,” said second-year chemistry graduate student Ben Zalisko, who spoke at the event.

The panel was divided into secularists and theists; PC had members on both sides.

The secularist panel argued for consequentialism and attacked faith as a basis of morality.

“We do things because of consequences, the Universe does not care about what we ought to do, Humans do,” Zalisko said. “Faith is the willful suspension of critical thinking; it poisons rational thought.”

In response, the theists argued that something objective and transcendent provides the reasoning to be moral.

“[Morality] has nothing to do with the desires of a person…the existence of God provides us a purpose,” third-year PC member Ajay Ravichandran said.

Third-year Paul Dueck of the InterVarsity Christian Fellowship furthered the argument. “Only transcendent things qualify as reasons to actually do something.”

Kremer concluded with a quote from Plato’s Euthyphro: “Is something good simply because God commands it, or does He command it because it is already good?”

Leave a Comment
Donate to Chicago Maroon
$560
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation makes the work of student journalists of University of Chicago possible and allows us to continue serving the UChicago and Hyde Park community.

More to Discover
Donate to Chicago Maroon
$560
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal

Comments (0)

All Chicago Maroon Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *