Dear President Alivisatos and Provost Baicker,
Allowing the continued encampment of protesters on our main quad imposes the following significant costs on the University:
- Time, Place, and Manner (TPM) restrictions are put in place to ensure that expression furthers the goal of intellectual exchange in the pursuit of truth. Flagrant violations of TPM restrictions undermine the purpose of the University.
- TPM restrictions are not being applied equally. If the University continues to allow TPM violations by these protestors, while enforcing TPM restrictions on other groups, it is effectively violating the principle of institutional neutrality outlined in the Kalven report.
- It prevents us from hearing opposing viewpoints since these protestors have repeatedly ripped down and removed posters, flags, and banners they disagree with and shouted down speakers they disagree with.
- It provides an incentive to engage in TPM violations and encourages future encampments. We risk chaos and the collapse of our ability to function as an institute of higher learning.
This flagrant violation of our academic values is not going to end unless you take decisive action to remove and sanction these protestors while firmly rejecting their demands.
Sincerely,
Dorian S. Abbot, Professor of Geophysical Sciences
Peggy Mason, Professor of Neurobiology
Callum F. Ross, Professor of Organismal Biology and Anatomy
Rick Shweder, Harold H. Swift Distinguished Service Professor of Comparative Human Development
Steve Kaplan, Neubauer Family Distinguished Service Professor, Booth School of Business
Jerry Coyne, Professor Emeritus of Ecology and Evolution
Micah T. Prochaska, Assistant Professor of Medicine
Sam Peltzman, Ralph and Dorothy Keller Distinguished Service Professor of Economics Emeritus
Casey B. Mulligan, Professor of Economics
Juan I. Collar, Professor of Physics
Rachel Fulton Brown, Associate Professor of Medieval History and Fundamentals
Andrew Aronsohn, Associate Professor of Medicine
Gautham Reddy, Associate Professor of Medicine
Adam Cifu, Professor of Medicine
Elliot S. Gershon, Professor Emeritus of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neuroscience
Shadi Bartsch-Zimmer, Helen A. Regenstein Distinguished Service Professor of Classics
Lawrence Grossman, Professor Emeritus of Geophysical Sciences
David Zarfes, Clinical Professor of Law
Emily Underwood, Associate Clinical Professor of Law
Kevin M. Murphy, George J. Stigler Distinguished Service Professor of Economics Emeritus
John Reinitz, Professor of Statistics, Molecular Genetics and Cell Biology; and Ecology and Evolution
László Babai, Bruce V. and Diana M. Rauner Distinguished Service Professor of Computer Science and Mathematics
Dario Maestripieri, Professor of Comparative Human Development
Shmuel Weinberger, Andrew MacLeish Distinguished Service Professor of Mathematics
Alexander Razborov, Andrew MacLeish Distinguished Service Professor of Mathematics and Computer Science
Robert H. Topel, Isidore Brown and Gladys J. Brown Distinguished Service Professor of Economics
Leslie Kay, Professor of Psychology
Allan Drummond, Associate Professor, Biochemistry and Molecular Biology
George Glauberman, Professor Emeritus of Mathematics
Russell D. Cohen, Professor of Medicine
Steven J. Davis, William H. Abbott Distinguished Service Professor of International Business and Economics Emeritus, Booth School of Business
Anil Kashyap, Stevens Distinguished Service Professor of Economics and Finance
Jing Chen, Janet Davison Rowley Distinguished Service Professor of Medicine
Lisa Bernstein, Wilson-Dickenson Professor of Law
Josh Avratin, Clinical Professor of Law
Benson Farb, Professor of Mathematics
Laurie Zoloth, Margaret E. Burton Professor of Religion and Ethics
Harald Uhlig, Bruce Allen and Barbara Ritzenthaler Professor of Economics
David Martinez, Associate Professor of Classics and the Divinity School
Richard Epstein, James Parker Hall Distinguished Service Professor Emeritus of Law
Greg Kaplan, Alvin H. Baum Professor of Economics
Dennis W. Carlton, David McDaniel Keller Professor of Economics Emeritus
Simeon Chavel, Associate Professor of Hebrew Bible in the Divinity School
Ross M. Stolzenberg, Professor of Sociology
Fernando Alvarez, Charles F. Gray Distinguished Service Professor in Economics
William Landes, Musser Professor of Law and Economics, Emeritus
PhD Candidate / May 5, 2024 at 9:18 pm
These faculty are simply intellectually bankrupt, blinded, and not committed to either humanism or inquiry. Shame on you all
Mark / May 4, 2024 at 10:45 am
Not sure what they’re talking about. There’s been numerous Israeli stands and exhibitions.
The encampment literally has posters up that says to not damage other installations.
The counter-protestors on Friday seemed to get their point across just fine.
Free Speech doesn’t depend on who signs a letter…
UC Faculty Member / May 3, 2024 at 1:23 pm
This entire argument rests on item 3. Pro-Israel posters are being ripped down, but there is no evidence that the protestors are the ones responsible. If there was evidence of responsibility, the President would have shared it.
Nor is there any evidence of anyone being “shouted down.” Who, pray tell, are these speakers who have been unable to speak? Please give specifics. Noise pollution in classrooms do not constitute “prevent[ing] us from hearing opposing viewpoints.”
You know what’s a flagrant violation of academic values, the Chicago principles, and institutional neutrality? Arresting a bunch of peaceful protesters for “disruption” that fails to go beyond mild inconvenience and annoyance.
Jay Tanzman / May 3, 2024 at 3:24 pm
A very brave comment, “UC Faculty Member.”
Lawrence Rothfield / May 5, 2024 at 11:35 am
How about addressing the argument rather than the name of the person making it?
Robert Gonzalez / May 3, 2024 at 7:02 pm
Clear evidence of what’s wrong with allowing this to continue.
Twitter @austinzeglis